Yesterday I posted my thoughts on who I felt were the greatest cast members in the history of Saturday Night Live, which of course got me thinking about its current cast. While they had an up and down season last year in my opinion, every cast member will be returning next season. With that in mind, I'll give you my thoughts on how the current SNL cast members stack up, so you'll be well aware of who you're most likely going to see...again.
The Current SNL Cast
14. Paul Brittain (2010 - Present) - Paul who? Exactly
13. Abby Elliot (2008 - Present) - Just did not get a lot of material on this year, and it's really been hit or miss when she does
12. Taran Killam (2010 - Present) - Doesn't do a bad job in supporting roles, but give him his own sketch (Les Jueves de Paris) and it might not go so well.
11. Jay Pharoh (2010 - Present) - Does he do anything that isn't a black celebrity impression? His impressions are brilliant, but he needs to broaden his range a lot.
10. Vanessa Bayer (2010 - Present) - The best of the newbies, the only one with a recurring sketch (The Miley Cyrus Show) along with several nice supporting roles. Easily the most visible of the new cast members this past season.
9. Nasim Pedrad (2009 - Present) - Still seen more in supporting roles, Nasim is a nice well rounded cast member that just needs to write herself better material for a hit sketch (because that girl who won't leave her parents is definitely never going to be a hit)
8. Bobby Moynihan (2008 - Present) - The guy still doesn't have a recurring sketch or hit character, but he breathes energy into every single one of his sketches and you can tell how excited he still is to be on Saturday Night Live. He looks like a great guy to hang out with, but still not the guy you'd give a movie deal.
7. Jason Sudekis (2005 - Present) - Ordinarily Sudekis would be much higher on this list, but this year he really took a step backward in his visibility on the show, most likely due to Will Forte's departure (Sudekis had partnered with him many times before) and Sudekis's focus on his movie career. It was a genuine shock that Sudekis returned for another season, but I don't think he'll stick around too much longer.
6. Kenan Thompson (2003 - Present) - Kenan has the opposite problem of Pedrad and Moynihan in that he has quite a few recurring characters, but they all have been sucked dry already. What Up With That and Scared Straight have been done, and it's time for them to go into retirement. While Kenan may drag out some sketches too long, his little bit character parts on Update or in a sketch are always a delight (Charlie Wrangle, The Rent is too Damn High)
5. Fred Armisen (2002 - Present) - The main reason that Armisen stays relevant every week on the show is because of Obama. If you think of what Armisen has been doing on the show minus Obama is hasn't been a lot this past year. Most likely he's suffering a little burnout seeing he's been on the show for quite some time. However, when he does get a sketch or two on he rarely disappoints.
4. Seth Meyers (2001 - Present) - Seth Meyers has the potential to be number 1 on this list: if he would just get a freakin' co-anchor. Update character pieces have become a little more frequent, because Meyers is simply at his best when he has someone to play off of. When Amy Poehler returned to host this season Update was awesome because the two have great chemistry, but when he's going solo the Meyer's Update is usually good, not great. It's still the most solid portion of the show most weeks, but it has the potential to be so much more.
3. Andy Samberg (2005 - Present) - The master of The Digital Shorts turned out some impressive shorts this year, three of which are now up for Emmys. Not only that, but Samberg did just about every role imaginable this year, he did impressions, big sketches, small Update pieces, and of course The Digital Shorts, and he was pretty dang good in most of them. Like all cast members he had some ups and downs, but Samberg definitely grabbed some more spotlight following Forte's departure.
2. Kristen Wiig (2005 - Present) - The star of the show for the past couple of years didn't do as much as usual this past year, probably because she was focused on her big movie Bridesmaids, which as many of you know opened to critical acclaim. Wiig has been retiring some of her old characters and sketches (take note Kenan) which has given her less to do, but she is still your best bet to turn a crappy sketch around. Wiig breathes an astonishing amount of life into each character she does, all while being really funny.
1. Bill Hader (2005 - Present) - No doubt about it, Hader was the big man on campus this year. He had Julian Assange, Charlie Sheen, and John Boehner for great impressions, as well as great turns in sketches that would have most likely failed without him. In my opinion, he was also the star of the funniest sketch of the year (Don you go rounnin my roun to re ro). Along with a number of great characters, Stefon now being the most recognizable but Herb Welch is one of my favorites, it's not suprise that Hader wants to come back and clean up some more.
Those of my thoughts on SNL's current cast, feel free to give me yours!
Friday, August 12, 2011
Thursday, August 11, 2011
Thoughts on Television - Greatest Saturday Night Live Cast Members
Since 1975, the best to way to launch yourself into comedic stardom has been to be a cast member on Saturday Night Live. The show has produced a staggering amount of famous alumni, spread throught the entertainment industry in television, film, stand-up and many more fields. One of the favorite things to do of longtime fans of the show is to create their "dream cast," assembled of who they feel are the greatest performers to ever grace the stage of studio 8H. As a longtime fan of the show, I also like to play this game, which is why I created the list you see below. The list is based solely on the cast member's contribution to Saturday Night Live, whether they became famous afterwards or flirted with obscurity afterwards is irrelevant. Current cast members are also being left off the list, as their contributions as a cast member will only be judged after they have left the show. The list is based solely on what they could do live from New York on Saturday Night.
Honorable Mentions
These are cast members that found themselves with just not enough to make it into the top ten, but that in no way belittles their contribution to the show. Just being among the best in a television show that produces the greatest comedic talent in the world is quite an accomplishment, I must say.
15. Molly Shannon - The first real female performer to really break out since Gilda Radner from the original cast. She started the new female revolution where the women on the show started to contribute just as the men, and soon the women began to overtake the men, though Shannon would not be present for that. Her iconic character Mary Katherin Gallagher also helped restore confidence in the show after its low ratings peak in the 94-95 season. However, Shannon was often still overshadowed by her male co-workers, specifically Will Ferrell.
14. Adam Sandler - Arguably the most unique voice to ever come on the show, Adam Sandler did Adam Sandler pieces, and he did them well. Sandler created some of the most original characters ever on the show, and while he worked his way up into becoming a major player on the show, his reputation is hurt by the fact that he and Chris Farely couldn't maintain the show during the 94-95 season and were both fired by NBC.
13. Billy Crystal - Billy was the star of Saturday Night Live from 84-85, but that was it. In one year Billy Crystal led the charge of what is considered one of SNL's best seasons, but unfortunately he was only around for one, which prevents him from moving up higher on this list. If he would've been around for another year or two, he would've solidified his reputation as one of the show's all time greatest cast members.
12. Amy Poehler - Taking over for Molly Shannon, Amy Poehler presided over a period of SNL where the girls weren't just as good as the boys, they were better. Throughout her time on the show, Poehler show us all that she didn't want to be considered the damsel in distress or the hot prize, she wanted to be the funny one. And she was.
11. Phil Hartman - One of the most versatile performers the show's had, Phil would do anything, and he did it well. It helped that he also had a golden voice to back up his tremendous acting skills. Hartman was good in everything, but he didn't have too many amazing stand out moments that would put him higher on the list. Still, every moment was a great one with Phil Hartman.
The Greats
10. Chevy Chase - SNL's original breakout star got the show off the ground, and lauched it 10,000 feet in the air. Though like Billy Crystal he was only on for one year, Chase's year on the show is much more iconic, famous for his prat falls, his bumbling impression of Gerald Ford, and his gig as Weekend Update Anchor. Chase helped make the show what it is today, which almost no other performer could do. But hey, after all, he's Chevy Chase, and we're not.
9. Chris Farley - The big man had skills. He created a bunch of the most famous recurring characters in the early 90's, and was head of the shows demographic swing to a younger generation. The guy seemed to be able to do it all, but even he couldn't keep the show afloat in the 94-95 season and was fired as a result. However his legacy lives on through all the tremendous energy and passion he would put in each sketch, so that a common way of fixing bad sketches was to just add "Farley enters."
8. Dan Akyroyd - One of the greatest writer/performers in SNL's history, Akyroyd would write some of the show's most inventive sketches while also creating a nice pile of recurring characters. His writing will always stick out more than his performing however, limiting his upward mobility on this list, but he will forever be a legend in 8H for all his contributions to making SNL a hit.
7. Gilda Radner - Everybody loved Gilda. While the later women of SNL would break out when the male talent started to dwindle a little, Gilda was among the best of the best, and still broke through the mold. Gilda helped carry the show each year during the show's five year run, and never ran out of steam. She was actually the show's only original star to have stuck around for those first five years, and it served her reputation well.
6. Mike Meyers - Meyers wasn't the kind of guy who would be in other people's sketches just so he would get on air that week. Mike Meyers just stuck to his Mike Meyers pieces, and he was never hungry for airtime. The creator of some of the most popular sketches the show's ever had, Meyers was also the star of the most successful SNL movie. It's also interesting to note that by the end of his run, Meyers had already become more famous than most of the SNL hosts.
5. Dana Carvey - During his run on the show, Dana Carvey was forced to compete with some of the show's greatest talents for airtime, and he won. Carvey was able to be on the show from top to bottom, starting with his George H.W. Bush impression. then starting the show strong with Church Chat or Garth from Wayne's World. (even though Wayne's World is Mike Meyers piece, it wouldn't be the same without Carvey) Unfortunately, while Carvey wasn't as successful outside of SNL as some of its stars have been, but his tenure on the show still remains absolutely brilliant.
4. Bill Murray - The first SNL replacement cast member, Bill Murray taught us that you not only have to equal the contributions of the person you replaced (a tall order for replacing Chevy Chase) but in order to be well like you have to surpass them. While Murray struggled at first, he finally found he way into our hearts, by telling us he was struggling. Not too long after that Murray found his spotlight on SNL as the show's first true everyman, as well as creating classic characters like the Nerds and Nick the Lounge Singer. The fact that the show could also lose two more of its stars, Belushi and Akyroyd and be able to stay alive and a hit is thanks to the amazing talents of Bill Murray.
3. Will Ferrell - While Carvey was able to be on the show from top to bottom, Will Ferrell could dominate a show. In the late 90's and early 2000's, there was no question: Will Ferrell was the star of SNL. Ferrell led the charge of restoring the show's glory after the disastrous 94-95 season, and he not only helped bring it back but made it one of the greatest times in the show's long career. Ferrell was able to walk the line perfectly between being known for characters and being known for impressions. In characters he had the Spartan Cheerleaders, A Night at the Roxbury, and his famous patriot that wore a very interesting outfit out of pride for his country. In impressions he had George W. Bush, Alex Trebek, Harry Carry, Neil Diamond and Robert Goulet. Ferrell had it all, and he had fun with it.
2. Eddie Murphy - There is no question about this, is the early 80's Eddie Murphy WAS SNL. Not just the star of it, he was it. After all the show's comedic talent moved away after the first five seasons Eddie gave us a reason to still care about SNL. He had Gumby, Buckwheat, and spent a day among white men in White Like Me. Eddie Murphy was a bundle of pure comedic genius, and he started out at only 18 years old.
1. John Belushi - Belushi was a very messed up man, but a brilliant performer. The greatness of John Belushi was that he could star in one sketch the entire night, and the rest would be Akyroyd, Radner and Murray, but all you could talk about the next day was John Belushi. He treated almost every moment of his time of the air as if it was his last, which was theoretically possibe, knowing his lifestyle. With perfect impressions and characters, Belushi lead the original cast of SNL to greatness and never looked back. An isatiable man, Belushi was as close as it comes to perfection.
Honorable Mentions
These are cast members that found themselves with just not enough to make it into the top ten, but that in no way belittles their contribution to the show. Just being among the best in a television show that produces the greatest comedic talent in the world is quite an accomplishment, I must say.
15. Molly Shannon - The first real female performer to really break out since Gilda Radner from the original cast. She started the new female revolution where the women on the show started to contribute just as the men, and soon the women began to overtake the men, though Shannon would not be present for that. Her iconic character Mary Katherin Gallagher also helped restore confidence in the show after its low ratings peak in the 94-95 season. However, Shannon was often still overshadowed by her male co-workers, specifically Will Ferrell.
14. Adam Sandler - Arguably the most unique voice to ever come on the show, Adam Sandler did Adam Sandler pieces, and he did them well. Sandler created some of the most original characters ever on the show, and while he worked his way up into becoming a major player on the show, his reputation is hurt by the fact that he and Chris Farely couldn't maintain the show during the 94-95 season and were both fired by NBC.
13. Billy Crystal - Billy was the star of Saturday Night Live from 84-85, but that was it. In one year Billy Crystal led the charge of what is considered one of SNL's best seasons, but unfortunately he was only around for one, which prevents him from moving up higher on this list. If he would've been around for another year or two, he would've solidified his reputation as one of the show's all time greatest cast members.
12. Amy Poehler - Taking over for Molly Shannon, Amy Poehler presided over a period of SNL where the girls weren't just as good as the boys, they were better. Throughout her time on the show, Poehler show us all that she didn't want to be considered the damsel in distress or the hot prize, she wanted to be the funny one. And she was.
11. Phil Hartman - One of the most versatile performers the show's had, Phil would do anything, and he did it well. It helped that he also had a golden voice to back up his tremendous acting skills. Hartman was good in everything, but he didn't have too many amazing stand out moments that would put him higher on the list. Still, every moment was a great one with Phil Hartman.
The Greats
10. Chevy Chase - SNL's original breakout star got the show off the ground, and lauched it 10,000 feet in the air. Though like Billy Crystal he was only on for one year, Chase's year on the show is much more iconic, famous for his prat falls, his bumbling impression of Gerald Ford, and his gig as Weekend Update Anchor. Chase helped make the show what it is today, which almost no other performer could do. But hey, after all, he's Chevy Chase, and we're not.
9. Chris Farley - The big man had skills. He created a bunch of the most famous recurring characters in the early 90's, and was head of the shows demographic swing to a younger generation. The guy seemed to be able to do it all, but even he couldn't keep the show afloat in the 94-95 season and was fired as a result. However his legacy lives on through all the tremendous energy and passion he would put in each sketch, so that a common way of fixing bad sketches was to just add "Farley enters."
8. Dan Akyroyd - One of the greatest writer/performers in SNL's history, Akyroyd would write some of the show's most inventive sketches while also creating a nice pile of recurring characters. His writing will always stick out more than his performing however, limiting his upward mobility on this list, but he will forever be a legend in 8H for all his contributions to making SNL a hit.
7. Gilda Radner - Everybody loved Gilda. While the later women of SNL would break out when the male talent started to dwindle a little, Gilda was among the best of the best, and still broke through the mold. Gilda helped carry the show each year during the show's five year run, and never ran out of steam. She was actually the show's only original star to have stuck around for those first five years, and it served her reputation well.
6. Mike Meyers - Meyers wasn't the kind of guy who would be in other people's sketches just so he would get on air that week. Mike Meyers just stuck to his Mike Meyers pieces, and he was never hungry for airtime. The creator of some of the most popular sketches the show's ever had, Meyers was also the star of the most successful SNL movie. It's also interesting to note that by the end of his run, Meyers had already become more famous than most of the SNL hosts.
5. Dana Carvey - During his run on the show, Dana Carvey was forced to compete with some of the show's greatest talents for airtime, and he won. Carvey was able to be on the show from top to bottom, starting with his George H.W. Bush impression. then starting the show strong with Church Chat or Garth from Wayne's World. (even though Wayne's World is Mike Meyers piece, it wouldn't be the same without Carvey) Unfortunately, while Carvey wasn't as successful outside of SNL as some of its stars have been, but his tenure on the show still remains absolutely brilliant.
4. Bill Murray - The first SNL replacement cast member, Bill Murray taught us that you not only have to equal the contributions of the person you replaced (a tall order for replacing Chevy Chase) but in order to be well like you have to surpass them. While Murray struggled at first, he finally found he way into our hearts, by telling us he was struggling. Not too long after that Murray found his spotlight on SNL as the show's first true everyman, as well as creating classic characters like the Nerds and Nick the Lounge Singer. The fact that the show could also lose two more of its stars, Belushi and Akyroyd and be able to stay alive and a hit is thanks to the amazing talents of Bill Murray.
3. Will Ferrell - While Carvey was able to be on the show from top to bottom, Will Ferrell could dominate a show. In the late 90's and early 2000's, there was no question: Will Ferrell was the star of SNL. Ferrell led the charge of restoring the show's glory after the disastrous 94-95 season, and he not only helped bring it back but made it one of the greatest times in the show's long career. Ferrell was able to walk the line perfectly between being known for characters and being known for impressions. In characters he had the Spartan Cheerleaders, A Night at the Roxbury, and his famous patriot that wore a very interesting outfit out of pride for his country. In impressions he had George W. Bush, Alex Trebek, Harry Carry, Neil Diamond and Robert Goulet. Ferrell had it all, and he had fun with it.
2. Eddie Murphy - There is no question about this, is the early 80's Eddie Murphy WAS SNL. Not just the star of it, he was it. After all the show's comedic talent moved away after the first five seasons Eddie gave us a reason to still care about SNL. He had Gumby, Buckwheat, and spent a day among white men in White Like Me. Eddie Murphy was a bundle of pure comedic genius, and he started out at only 18 years old.
1. John Belushi - Belushi was a very messed up man, but a brilliant performer. The greatness of John Belushi was that he could star in one sketch the entire night, and the rest would be Akyroyd, Radner and Murray, but all you could talk about the next day was John Belushi. He treated almost every moment of his time of the air as if it was his last, which was theoretically possibe, knowing his lifestyle. With perfect impressions and characters, Belushi lead the original cast of SNL to greatness and never looked back. An isatiable man, Belushi was as close as it comes to perfection.
Thursday, July 28, 2011
Thoughts on Movies - Best and Worst Comedy Films in 2011
Well, the year is already over halfway over, so while I won't go into a full detailed list of the Best and Worst of Comedy Films in 2011, I will still provide what I feel is the best and worst in this genre so far this year.
Worst Comedy Film in 2011: The Hangover Part II
Honestly, I'm a big fan of the first Hangover, but this selection was a no-brainer. Recycling the same plot in a different location, the screenwriter's thought that the best way to keep the movie fresh was to jack up the raunchiness a couple ten notches. The result is a way over the top film that doesn't realize extreme raunchiness and character development don't go hand in hand. It also grossed over $500 million worldwide....Hangover Part III here we come.
Best Comedy Film in 2011: Bridesmaids
This selection was also a no brainer. Kristen Wiig steps off of SNL and into the spotlight in a wonderfully hilarious movie that also has heart to it and real characters. While The Hangover Part II embraced stereotypes and exploited them (Leslie Chow, I'm sorry Ken Jeong, but it's true), Bridesmaids did the opposite and took what would be one joke sterotype characters and made them fleshed out and likeable (Melissa McCarthy). While Bridesmaids didn't earn as much money box office wise as The Hangover Part II did, I'm sure it'll be replayed many more times than that other shoddy sequel.
Worst Comedy Film in 2011: The Hangover Part II
Honestly, I'm a big fan of the first Hangover, but this selection was a no-brainer. Recycling the same plot in a different location, the screenwriter's thought that the best way to keep the movie fresh was to jack up the raunchiness a couple ten notches. The result is a way over the top film that doesn't realize extreme raunchiness and character development don't go hand in hand. It also grossed over $500 million worldwide....Hangover Part III here we come.
Best Comedy Film in 2011: Bridesmaids
This selection was also a no brainer. Kristen Wiig steps off of SNL and into the spotlight in a wonderfully hilarious movie that also has heart to it and real characters. While The Hangover Part II embraced stereotypes and exploited them (Leslie Chow, I'm sorry Ken Jeong, but it's true), Bridesmaids did the opposite and took what would be one joke sterotype characters and made them fleshed out and likeable (Melissa McCarthy). While Bridesmaids didn't earn as much money box office wise as The Hangover Part II did, I'm sure it'll be replayed many more times than that other shoddy sequel.
Wednesday, July 27, 2011
Thoughts on Music - Album Review of Alpocalypse
Since the 1970's, Weird Al Yankovic has kept us entertained and chuckling with novelty parody songs spoofing popular music and artists. Here in 2011, Weird Al is still at it, with his latest album Alpocalypse. Right off the bat, this album might sadden some Weird Al fans, as five of the songs on the album have already been released in Yankovic's Grammy nominated EP Internet Leaks. The rest of the songs prove that Yankovic might not being in his glory days anymore, with almost all the songs being decent parodies, but nowhere close to providing a gut-busting laugh or causing us to sing along. The lone exception is his parody of Lady Gaga's "Born this Way," which he turns into "Perform this Way." This song proves to be the highlight of the album, as Yankovic discusses an artist with an extremely eccentric stage personality.
Final Grade: C+
Final Analysis: Not a bad album, but not really a good one either
Final Grade: C+
Final Analysis: Not a bad album, but not really a good one either
Tuesday, July 26, 2011
Thoughts on Music - Album Review of Turtleneck and Chain
The Saturday Night Live trio of Andy Samberg, Jorma Taccone and Akiva Schaffer have been busting out hilarious novelty songs ever since striking gold with the Digital Short "Lazy Sunday." Since then, the group has won an Emmy for their songwriting abilities, as well as earning several Emmy and Grammy nominations. Turtleneck and Chain is the group's second full length album, comprised half of songs that were already featured in an SNL Digital short as well as a few new songs. This resulting album is a roller coaster of highs and lows, with songs like "I Just Had Sex" "Jack Sparrow" and "Motherlover" arguably topping Weird Al's biggest hits. The three men also prove they are well listened music scholars, being able to perfectly imitate the genres they spoof, like classical R & B and current gangsta rap to name a few. Another thing the dudes have going for them is that all their songs are unbelievably catchy, even when the lyrical content fails to produce many laughs. On the flip side, just because all the songs are catchy doesn't mean all of them are good. Some feel directionless, with missed comedic points or too much emphasis on a single comedic idea to carry a song. However, The Lonely Island still manage to deliver a hilarious album, proving that they are worthy of being called this generations new Weird Al, because as much as some of their songs fail to deliver, they're still better than what most of their competition is doing.
Final Grade: B
Final Analysis: If you like music and you like to laugh, this album would definitely be a good one to have.
Final Grade: B
Final Analysis: If you like music and you like to laugh, this album would definitely be a good one to have.
Monday, July 25, 2011
Thoughts on Movies - A Young White Guy's Top 25 Comedy Movies of All Time
Here it is, my list of what I consider to be the Top 25 Comedy Movies of all time. I tried to be honest and stray away from personal preferences (Anchorman) so this could be considered a truly validated list. However, as I have no qualifications and this list is completely subjective, this list isn't that valid anyway. I tried to create a variety of movies on this list, but I doubt I was very successful. As you will see the list will be completely unordered, because I think it would be completely narcissistic of me to claim that I can tell which laugh is better than which. When it comes to the best, I honestly think there is no way to rank them fairly and say "This is it. This is the list." Instead, I put the movies in order of their release date, so you can see the different ways movies have made us laugh all throughout the years.
The Gold Rush - 1925
You have to give Charlie Chaplain his dues as one of the first great comedy icons, and I try to honor him by including on this list the film he said he wanted to be remembered for most. Any movie that can produce laughs without even sound deserves a little credit, in my opinion.
Duck Soup - 1933
A classic Marx Brothers comedy that earns its place of this list because no one did it like the Marx's back then. No one does has done it like them since. I doubt anyone ever will.
Some Like it Hot - 1959
The classic crossdressing comedy with Marilyn Monroe has always produced laughs even though it was released over 50 years ago. With one of the best closing lines I've ever seen in a movie it stays true to the comedians number one goal: always leave them wanting more.
Dr. Strangelove or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb - 1964
It's hard to imagine may comedians nowadays satirizing a nuclear scare. It's even harder to imagine that they would do that in the thick of the Cold War, right after the Cuban Missle Crisis almost caused human annihilation. This film has more guts than almost every comedy movie in the last 25 years combined, making it a clear classic.
The Producers - 1968
Mel Brooks first turn at writing and directing a film ended up winning him an Academy Award for his screenplay, multiple Tony awards when he turned it into a musical, as well as a Grammy Award for the cast album. Brooks was arguably at his finest early on, satirizing Hitler and Nazi Germany long before it became cool to do so with one of the most offensive and hilarious songs ever written, the classic "Springtime for Hitler."
Blazing Saddles - 1974
While The Producers may have been overall the best work Mel Brooks has ever done, Blazing Saddles was probably his funniest. Written with the help of comedy legend Richard Pryor, this movie contained a scene containing the most farts in film history, and still got three Academy Award nominations. Pure genius.
Young Frankenstein - 1974
Mel Brooks showed us once again his pure directing genius by managing to re-create the atmosphere of a 1930s to 1940s horror film, in all its black and white glory, and making it entertaining to watch. He also provided us with a genius Fred Astaire number...not by Fred Astaire.
Monty Python and the Holy Grail - 1975
How could this movie not make the list? Over 35 years after its release it still manages to be one of the most quoteable and entertaining movies ever made. It doesn't hurt that it now also has a musical counterpart that won multiple Tony Awards, including Best Musical. Yes, the boys of Monty Python were clearly at their greatest here, and the Middle Ages will never be seen the same way because of it.
Annie Hall - 1977
You can tell this movie was pure gold because it managed to get an Oscar nomination for Woddy Allen...for his acting. Allen managed to add a little bit more depth to his next comedy and the results were astounding. Even if you're not an Allen fan, it's hard to knock this Academy Award winning picture.
National Lampoon's Animal House - 1978
The film that did the impossible: made John Belushi an even bigger star. The film so packed with quotes, mischief and fun that when I first saw it I wanted to drop everything and go to college a couple years early. Spawning off an entire genre of films where our laughs are traced with a little bit of disgust, this movie magic has never been able to be repeated.
Airplane! - 1980
The movie that turned a stupid comment into a somehow memorable and genius quote had a lot going for it, and still does. "Good luck, we're all counting on you," to make us laugh, that is. Luckily, this movie never disappoints.
Caddyshack - 1980
The movie that launched Bill Murray into stardom, purely on his improvised lines as Carl the groundskeeper.This wonderful Cinderella story is a pure delight and never loses its cache, even when my father quotes it daily. Very, very few movies have that kind of prestige.
National Lampoon's Vacation - 1983
Chevy Chase's shot at stardom spawned off an entire new genre of failed family vacation movies, nothing even close to what Chase and the Griswolds were first able to capture in this movie, a classic comedy that only lost some of its dignity because of its less than thrilling sequels.
Beverly Hills Cop - 1984
As I have grown up mainly with the pop culture of the 2000s, I am cursed with not being able to remember a time when Eddie Murphy was a beloved and well respected comedy icon. Luckily for him, films are timeless, and he shines wonderfully in his performance when he was a much younger, and much more well respected, comedian.
Ghostbusters - 1984
When I was much younger, around 4 or 5, and I first saw parts of Ghostbusters, I couldn't comprehend what the dialougue was, so I thought Ghostbusters was a serious action movie about people who fought ghosts. This made it all the better for me rediscovering Ghostbusters later as a genius comedy film, because it visually looked like an action film, pushing the limits of special effects of the time, but its dialougue betrayed that it was actually one of the greatest comedy movies of all time.
This is Spinal Tap - 1984
Before The Office managed to make the mockumentary style of camera work famous, this fake documentary manged to turn the laughs up to 11. The fake rock band Spinal Tap even managed to make real rockers sides ache, and both Eddie Van Halen and The Edge of U2 were reportably stunned at how accurately the film managed to portray rock life. Spinal Tap is now given serious attention as one of the most influential rock bands, silencing those mean critics who simply called their album Shark sandwhich: "shit sandwhich."
Ferris Bueller's Day Off - 1986
Don't we all just wish we could randomly take a day off from school or work or whatever, and have the time of our lives? Ferris Bueller's legendary day inspired all of us who watched it to go out and enjoy ourselves because sometimes, one day is all you need for a great adventure.
The Princess Bride - 1987
While its medieval setting sometimes puts it in a unwinnable contest with itself and Monty Python and the Holy Grail, this film is still memorable and extremely quoteable, sometimes to the point of blissful exhaustion. (My name is Inigo Montoya, you killed my father, prepare to die)
A Fish Called Wanda - 1988
Monty Python member John Cleese moves on from his sketch comedy brothers, co-writing and co-directing a new movie, and the result is to die for. Literally, it's rumored this movie caused someone to die from laughter. Enough said.
Groundhog Day - 1993
Stuck in the same day over and over again, Bill Murray provides us with some unforgettable hijinxs, and later he provides us with a beautiful message and implored us to make every day from now on count. That being said, my favorite scene is still the one where Murray and the groundhog go driving.
The Big Lebowski - 1998
It might surprise people now that an acclaimed actor like Jeff Bridges got his big start with a character known simply as "The Dude." Yet the Dude was an unforgettable character, just like the many characters that surround the Dude are pretty unforgettable, played by such actors as John Goodman and Julianne Moore. Oh, and did I mention that before their multiple Academy Awards and nominations, this is what the Coen brothers directed? I didn't....well they did.
There's Something About Mary - 1998
Brett Favre is in this movie. That should give you a hint as to how awesome this movie is. Of course, it also has Cameron Diaz and Ben Stiller, in one of their best performances to date, but personally I think it's just cool that Favre happens to be there, in one of the great cameo moments in movie history.
Office Space - 1999
The ultimate office comedy, before even Ricky Gervais had concieved it. And I don't think even he could have predicted the awesomeness of the world's best stapeler joke. Plus the trashing of the copier has got to be one of the greatest action sequences ever made, full of violence, emotion and hilarity. It's certainly a better sequence than anything Transformers has done.
South Park: Bigger Longer and Uncut - 1999
Matt Stone and Trey Parker teamed up to create of the most offensive but funniest shows in existance. So what did they do with that show? Why turn it into not just a movie, an animated movie, but an animated movie musical. The result rivals even what Disney has done with the movie musical, a hilarious movie making fun of the very people who are offended by it, as it made it into the Guniess World Record Book for most swear words in a movie.
The 40 Year Old Virgin - 2004
You'd think a movie with a title like this would not exactly be among the comedy greats, but it turns out to be a genius heartfelt comedy that doesn't settle for the easy laughs and keeps its tone as a wonderfully hilarious film. Steve Carrell is in one of the roles of his career and his three supporting men, as well as Jane Lynch, aren't so bad either. Probably the comedy film that mostly defined the rest of the decade, as after directing this movie Judd Apatow firmly rooted himself as one of the primary directors/producers of comedy films in the business.
Well, that's the list folks, and as they say, always leave them wanting more....well, I probably didn't do so well there...
The Gold Rush - 1925
You have to give Charlie Chaplain his dues as one of the first great comedy icons, and I try to honor him by including on this list the film he said he wanted to be remembered for most. Any movie that can produce laughs without even sound deserves a little credit, in my opinion.
Duck Soup - 1933
A classic Marx Brothers comedy that earns its place of this list because no one did it like the Marx's back then. No one does has done it like them since. I doubt anyone ever will.
Some Like it Hot - 1959
The classic crossdressing comedy with Marilyn Monroe has always produced laughs even though it was released over 50 years ago. With one of the best closing lines I've ever seen in a movie it stays true to the comedians number one goal: always leave them wanting more.
Dr. Strangelove or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb - 1964
It's hard to imagine may comedians nowadays satirizing a nuclear scare. It's even harder to imagine that they would do that in the thick of the Cold War, right after the Cuban Missle Crisis almost caused human annihilation. This film has more guts than almost every comedy movie in the last 25 years combined, making it a clear classic.
The Producers - 1968
Mel Brooks first turn at writing and directing a film ended up winning him an Academy Award for his screenplay, multiple Tony awards when he turned it into a musical, as well as a Grammy Award for the cast album. Brooks was arguably at his finest early on, satirizing Hitler and Nazi Germany long before it became cool to do so with one of the most offensive and hilarious songs ever written, the classic "Springtime for Hitler."
Blazing Saddles - 1974
While The Producers may have been overall the best work Mel Brooks has ever done, Blazing Saddles was probably his funniest. Written with the help of comedy legend Richard Pryor, this movie contained a scene containing the most farts in film history, and still got three Academy Award nominations. Pure genius.
Young Frankenstein - 1974
Mel Brooks showed us once again his pure directing genius by managing to re-create the atmosphere of a 1930s to 1940s horror film, in all its black and white glory, and making it entertaining to watch. He also provided us with a genius Fred Astaire number...not by Fred Astaire.
Monty Python and the Holy Grail - 1975
How could this movie not make the list? Over 35 years after its release it still manages to be one of the most quoteable and entertaining movies ever made. It doesn't hurt that it now also has a musical counterpart that won multiple Tony Awards, including Best Musical. Yes, the boys of Monty Python were clearly at their greatest here, and the Middle Ages will never be seen the same way because of it.
Annie Hall - 1977
You can tell this movie was pure gold because it managed to get an Oscar nomination for Woddy Allen...for his acting. Allen managed to add a little bit more depth to his next comedy and the results were astounding. Even if you're not an Allen fan, it's hard to knock this Academy Award winning picture.
National Lampoon's Animal House - 1978
The film that did the impossible: made John Belushi an even bigger star. The film so packed with quotes, mischief and fun that when I first saw it I wanted to drop everything and go to college a couple years early. Spawning off an entire genre of films where our laughs are traced with a little bit of disgust, this movie magic has never been able to be repeated.
Airplane! - 1980
The movie that turned a stupid comment into a somehow memorable and genius quote had a lot going for it, and still does. "Good luck, we're all counting on you," to make us laugh, that is. Luckily, this movie never disappoints.
Caddyshack - 1980
The movie that launched Bill Murray into stardom, purely on his improvised lines as Carl the groundskeeper.This wonderful Cinderella story is a pure delight and never loses its cache, even when my father quotes it daily. Very, very few movies have that kind of prestige.
National Lampoon's Vacation - 1983
Chevy Chase's shot at stardom spawned off an entire new genre of failed family vacation movies, nothing even close to what Chase and the Griswolds were first able to capture in this movie, a classic comedy that only lost some of its dignity because of its less than thrilling sequels.
Beverly Hills Cop - 1984
As I have grown up mainly with the pop culture of the 2000s, I am cursed with not being able to remember a time when Eddie Murphy was a beloved and well respected comedy icon. Luckily for him, films are timeless, and he shines wonderfully in his performance when he was a much younger, and much more well respected, comedian.
Ghostbusters - 1984
When I was much younger, around 4 or 5, and I first saw parts of Ghostbusters, I couldn't comprehend what the dialougue was, so I thought Ghostbusters was a serious action movie about people who fought ghosts. This made it all the better for me rediscovering Ghostbusters later as a genius comedy film, because it visually looked like an action film, pushing the limits of special effects of the time, but its dialougue betrayed that it was actually one of the greatest comedy movies of all time.
This is Spinal Tap - 1984
Before The Office managed to make the mockumentary style of camera work famous, this fake documentary manged to turn the laughs up to 11. The fake rock band Spinal Tap even managed to make real rockers sides ache, and both Eddie Van Halen and The Edge of U2 were reportably stunned at how accurately the film managed to portray rock life. Spinal Tap is now given serious attention as one of the most influential rock bands, silencing those mean critics who simply called their album Shark sandwhich: "shit sandwhich."
Ferris Bueller's Day Off - 1986
Don't we all just wish we could randomly take a day off from school or work or whatever, and have the time of our lives? Ferris Bueller's legendary day inspired all of us who watched it to go out and enjoy ourselves because sometimes, one day is all you need for a great adventure.
The Princess Bride - 1987
While its medieval setting sometimes puts it in a unwinnable contest with itself and Monty Python and the Holy Grail, this film is still memorable and extremely quoteable, sometimes to the point of blissful exhaustion. (My name is Inigo Montoya, you killed my father, prepare to die)
A Fish Called Wanda - 1988
Monty Python member John Cleese moves on from his sketch comedy brothers, co-writing and co-directing a new movie, and the result is to die for. Literally, it's rumored this movie caused someone to die from laughter. Enough said.
Groundhog Day - 1993
Stuck in the same day over and over again, Bill Murray provides us with some unforgettable hijinxs, and later he provides us with a beautiful message and implored us to make every day from now on count. That being said, my favorite scene is still the one where Murray and the groundhog go driving.
The Big Lebowski - 1998
It might surprise people now that an acclaimed actor like Jeff Bridges got his big start with a character known simply as "The Dude." Yet the Dude was an unforgettable character, just like the many characters that surround the Dude are pretty unforgettable, played by such actors as John Goodman and Julianne Moore. Oh, and did I mention that before their multiple Academy Awards and nominations, this is what the Coen brothers directed? I didn't....well they did.
There's Something About Mary - 1998
Brett Favre is in this movie. That should give you a hint as to how awesome this movie is. Of course, it also has Cameron Diaz and Ben Stiller, in one of their best performances to date, but personally I think it's just cool that Favre happens to be there, in one of the great cameo moments in movie history.
Office Space - 1999
The ultimate office comedy, before even Ricky Gervais had concieved it. And I don't think even he could have predicted the awesomeness of the world's best stapeler joke. Plus the trashing of the copier has got to be one of the greatest action sequences ever made, full of violence, emotion and hilarity. It's certainly a better sequence than anything Transformers has done.
South Park: Bigger Longer and Uncut - 1999
Matt Stone and Trey Parker teamed up to create of the most offensive but funniest shows in existance. So what did they do with that show? Why turn it into not just a movie, an animated movie, but an animated movie musical. The result rivals even what Disney has done with the movie musical, a hilarious movie making fun of the very people who are offended by it, as it made it into the Guniess World Record Book for most swear words in a movie.
The 40 Year Old Virgin - 2004
You'd think a movie with a title like this would not exactly be among the comedy greats, but it turns out to be a genius heartfelt comedy that doesn't settle for the easy laughs and keeps its tone as a wonderfully hilarious film. Steve Carrell is in one of the roles of his career and his three supporting men, as well as Jane Lynch, aren't so bad either. Probably the comedy film that mostly defined the rest of the decade, as after directing this movie Judd Apatow firmly rooted himself as one of the primary directors/producers of comedy films in the business.
Well, that's the list folks, and as they say, always leave them wanting more....well, I probably didn't do so well there...
Thursday, July 14, 2011
Thoughts on Movies Preview
Well as of right now this blog is going extremely strong with approximately...0 views. Awesome. Not even my mom...who I gave this url too....sad. Oh well, I'm still going to forge ahead in the hopes that someone will read this. Unfortunately, I will be out of town for a week starting tomorrow and I will be unable to post further updates. So, in that case, when I return I will give a special treat for anyone who cares to read this: A Young White Guy's Top 25 Comedy Movies of All Time. I hope to give descriptions on the old classics as well as some more modern films that are still able to make our sides ache. I know that all 0 of you are just bursting with anticipation as to what this list will include, but you'll just have to wait until I come back. If you actually stop and read this, I owe you one, and I hope this lived up to at least your lowest expectations.
Thoughts on Television - 2011 Emmy Nominations
The 2011 Emmy Nominations were announced today, so naturally I and half of the western world will now discuss how we felt we triumphed due to someone else's success, or how we feel miserably disappointed because something we had nothing to do with didn't get picked. Since this is a comedy blog I will be going over the main comedy categories, as well as some of the variety categories (since almost every variety program nominated is aimed at making people laugh) as well as looking where comedy is making some suprise showings. I will share my hopes on what I want to be the victor, and what I think the Academy of Arts and Sciences will actually pick.
Outstanding Comedy Series
The Big Kahuna. Currently held by ABC's Modern Family, 4 nominees from 2010 return again, as well as two "new" series who are first time nominees even though they are both a few seasons into their run.
The Nominees
30 Rock - Tina Fey's quirky show is back for its 5th nomination in 5 years. While its 5th season is not its best, most comedies would kill for what 30 Rock would consider an average season. It is still one of the most brilliantly written shows on television, and to match that it has wonderful actors, who have garnered 6 acting nominations for the show this year. (Alec Baldwin, Tina Fey for Lead, Jane Krakowski for Supporting and Will Arnett, Matt Damon and Elizabeth Banks for Guest)
The Big Bang Theory - Finally getting its 1st nomination for its 4th season, many diehard nerdy fans are screaming happily because their show is finally getting recognition. As it should, it being one of the highest rated comedies currently on air, as well as getting a little bump when one of its stars, Jim Parsons, recieved the Emmy for Lead Actor in a Comedy Series last year. This year, Parson returns to the lead actor ballot, as well as his co-star Johnny Galecki, showing that this show is starting to resonate a little with the Emmy voters.
Glee - It was no question that this hit show would be back for another nomination in this category. I'm not sure if it's right though. While admittedly I was a hardcore Gleek last year and still watched every episode this year, my affection for this show is starting to fade. It's really not even that funny anymore, it has added many more dramatic elements this year as the teens struggle with real life issues, most notably Kurt Hummel's struggles as an out gay teenager. While it did make for some interesting and moving moments, almost none of them made me laugh. Also, the teen's romances are starting to get hard to keep track of, as well as being portrayed almost ridiculouslly unrealistic, which might be there attempt at humor. While still a fine series, Glee has even less evidence to call itself a comedy than last year.
Modern Family - The returning champs return for their 2nd nomination just as everyone and their newborn child could tell they would. There's not much more to say about it than that.
The Office - While the show has definetly hasn't been at its comedic highpoint for about 3 or 4 years, it was pretty much obvious the show would be nominated again for Steve Carrell's departure, especially since his departure was quite well done. Now, the question remains, will the show be able to get nominated again without Carrell? The show needs to re-invent itself and get back to its great mix of wonderful character moments and suprise laughs that its 2nd and 3rd (and to some extent 4th and 5th, though not nearly as well) season showed us.
Parks and Recreation - Its about time. I'm glad this highly undervalued show is finally getting its full turn in the limelight, after only getting a taste last year with Poehler's Lead Actress nomination (a feat she repeats again this year). It seems that adding Rob Lowe and Adam Scott to the cast has finally put this hilarious satire of small town government over the top, though the standouts still remain Poehler and Nick Offerman whose chemistry and character development have been great and led to some wonderful moments. While not the best show out there, it definitely deserves its spot among the nominees.
Who was Left Out
Nurse Jackie - This show, and by extension, all half comedies (The Big C, Weeds) except for Glee, was left out of the race this year. It seems life the Academy was wondering last year if these shows could stand with the pure comedies and compete head to head by giving Nurse Jackie a nomination for Outstanding Comedy Series. It seems that it ended up not being able to compete, so the Academy is instead honoring the more pure comedy shows (The Big Bang Theory, Parks and Recreation) rather than honoring more shows that give us a mix between the comedic and the dramatic.
Community - I am not going to lie to you, I am a big fan of this show. Along with Parks and Recreation, it is one of the dark-horses of NBC's Thursday night line-up. However, one of the best parts of this show, how its style changes almost every week to satarize the many genres and cliches of pop culture, is probaly not going to win over the Academy as much as a show that can prove it can be consistently funny in a single style. While I am a little sad it wasn't nominated, the fact that Parks and Recreation made the cut means I honestly can't complain, and it gives me hope that one day this great show will have its spot in the limelight too.
What my Heart says - Parks and Recreation, just to mess with every major pundit out there
What my Brain says - Modern Family. With Glee taking a more dramatic turn, this show should be clear for another win.
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series
This category was probably the most open category of the year in 2011. Long time nominees Larry David, Tony Schaloub and Charlie Sheen were all ineligible this year,(for different reasons) leading to 3 new nominees. Next year, as we all know, another spot is going to open up, so the big question is will this finally be the year of Carrell?
The Nominees
Alec Baldwin in 30 Rock - Alec Baldwin bags his 5th nomination for portraying Jack Donaghy on 30 Rock, to no one's suprise. Baldwin represents to me the best in a comedy actor, complete and utter devotion to his character whether he's making a speech about how American needs to innovate...by creating women's porn, or talking to 3 of his alternate reality selves. Baldwin utters every single word with complete determination and never attempts an extra laugh by giving the audience the "nudge-nudge, I just told a joke" approach, which I have always highly admired him for.
Steve Carrell in The Office - Is is finally his year? After being shut out in his first five nominations, will Steve Carrell finally take home the golden statue for Michael Scott's departure? I hope so. In Michael's farewell Carrell gave us a great mix of laughter and tears as he says goodbye in the only way he knows how. While not always inducing attacks on our sides, Carrell is a master at building up huge amounts of awkward tension whenever Michael goes to far, a skill that has been undervalued for 5 years, and I sure hope not for a 6th
Louis C.K. in Louie - A suprise nomination, but certainly a well deserved one, and I'm glad about 1,000,000 television cynics can now shut their traps. Louis C.K. has often been called the hardest working man in television, seeing how he oversees almost every detail that goes into making his FX sitcom, Louie. Cynics have long been predicting this year how C.K. deserved a nomination but "the elite at the Academy likely won't see what a wonderful show and performance C.K. give us, they hate good things" so sit down and shut up, you got what you wanted.
Johnny Galecki in The Big Bang Theory - In reality Parsons's second banana, there's no way that Galecki will ever take home the golden idol unless Parsons character mysteriously dies. However, it is nice that he is being honored for his performance along with his show getting its first ever Outstanding Comedy Series nomination. It's well deserved, and he will finally get his own turn in the spotlight after his co-star turned a lot of heads last year with his Emmy win.
Matt LeBlanc in Episodes - Welcome back Joey. Matt LeBlanc is now a member of an exclusive group of people who have been honored with accolades to portray...themselves. LeBlanc now joins the ranks of Bill Cosby and Jerry Seinfeld in actors who have been able to garner acclaim by portraying a fictional version of themselves of television. However, playing yourself isn't always as easy as it seems, and it's good that LeBlanc bounced back to something after the failure of his Friends spin-off.
Jim Parsons in The Big Bang Theory - The returning champ is back, but this time he brought his series with him into a nomination. While another win doesn't seem extremely likely for Parsons, especially due to Carrell's departure, he still continuously puts forth a fine performance and is very worthy of another nomination.
Who was Left Out
Matthew Morrison in Glee - Morrison does not recieve his 2nd nomination for Glee. This year, the spotlight has shown more on the students than the teacher, and it looks like the Academy figured that out.
Joel McHale in Community - Many people thought McHale would finally get Community some Emmy recognition, but it seems that he lost out to C.K. and Galecki. At least he left some people something to complain about.
What my Heart Says - Louis C.K., just because blogs and reporters everywhere will need to find something new to complain about
What my Brain Says - Steve Carrell, I think finally it's his year. and now he won't have to steal Ricky Gervais's Emmy any more
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series
3 new actresses compete for TV's top award, in the category with a few suprise upsets. 1 spot was left open by Julia Louis-Dreyfus but two nominees from 2010 were overturned.
Edie Falco in Nurse Jackie - Last year, Falco got the golden statue for Lead Actress in a Comedy Series, even though, and she said it herself, she's "not funny." While Falco is a great actress I wish they would give this award to someone who is actually comedic. However, since her show is now out of the Outstanding Comedy Series line-up it isn't likely Falco will get repeat statues.
Tina Fey in 30 Rock - Fey earns her 5th nomination, despite her own insistance that she "can't act." While I do think Fey is hilarious and does have acting skill, is she the best? I really don't think so. Most of Fey's reactions on the show involved her being frustrated with something, her co-workers, her actors, her boyfriend, her ex-lovers or her mentor Jack. While Fey still manages to make her frustration funny 5 seasons in, I don't think it should be enough to win.
Laura Linney in The Big C - Linney joins Falco as the two actresses who managed to get a nomination without exactly being "funny." As much as it pains me unfortunately there's not really enough lead female vehicles viable for the top award to take away Linney's spot. While she's a good actress, she's not extremely funny and that's what I believe this category should be about, but her performance still deserves credit.
Melissa McCarthy in Mike & Molly - This morning Melissa McCarthy announced the 2011 Emmy nominations, only to discover that she would be among the nominees. What followed was cool to watch, seeing a nominee react on camera to their nomination. While this is suprising, it would be far more suprising in McCarthy did not have a hilarious supporting role in Kristen Wiig's movie Bridesmaids, which I'm sure some of the Emmy voters saw which was able to put McCarthy into the minds of the voters.
Martha Plimpton in Raising Hope - Another suprise nominee, once again giving the cynics less to complain about. Plimpton now is the face of the Fox network in this category, because the actress that was Fox's only nominee last year, Lea Michele, has been dropped this year. Plimpton is getting her show some much needed attention, sneaking Raising Hope into the minds of the Emmy voters, something that many shows have yet to do (Community).
Amy Poehler in Parks and Recreation - Poehler has achieved her 2nd nomination for Parks and now she dragged her show up with her, and she doesn't seem to be stopping. Poehler was the 1st one to get her show recognition from critics with her quirky, brilliant and optimistic portrayal of a woman who LIKES to work in government. I can only hope she rides it straight to the top, because she doesn't seem to be slowing down anytime soon.
Who was Left Out
Lea Michele in Glee - Michele suffered the same fate of her on screen teacher Morrison this year, albeit to a lesser extent. Glee is very much becoming an ensemble show, which unfortunately for Michele makes each individual performance less notable unless you're the only one on the show able to carry certain storylines (Chris Colfer).
Toni Collette in United States of Tara - Collette won the award in 2009 and was renominated in 2010 but it seems this year that she's fallen off the map. Collette's performance I believe also belongs in the comedy nether-world with Falco and Linney, so it's quite possible it was decided that three semi-comedic performances was too much on the ballot and Linney eclipsed Collette.
What my Heart Says - Amy Poehler, because she's a funny person in a comedic category, shocking
What my Brain Says - Edie Falco or Laura Linney, in a category with not too many standouts one of the semi-comics is likely to take home the prize
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series
Sadly, though supporting comedic performances are often the funniest because they don't require the depth that leads do, this is the category I'll probably be paying the least attention to, due to reasons you'll see.
The Nominees
The Modern Family Boys: Ty Burrell, Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Ed O'Neill, and Eric Stonestreet in Modern Family - This year, instead of half the supporting actor nods the Modern Family Boys take up two-thirds in what I think is a cowardly attempt to get awards while shutting out other great performances. Modern Family nominates none of its actors in the Lead categories, only in supporting, which is why they take up so many of the nominations. This way, they don't have to deal with the higher level competition in the Lead categories. I'm not saying the performances are bad. They're obviously good enough to continue sweeping the supporting categories for years to come. I just wish the show would've had the guts to risk something on a Lead Actor nomination so it could share the supporting spotlight, not hog it.
Jon Cryer in Two and a Half Men - A suprising nomination in that everyone had just about counted him out due to his co-stars blow-up. But this former winner is back for what could be his last nomination, if Ashton Kutcher can't save the show next year. I think this was more of a sympathy pick for the Academy, showing that they still respect Cryer even as everyone lost respect for Charlie Sheen and his show in the process. As much as I would like to show Cryer sympathy, it makes me sad that one of only two spots not given to Modern Family was possibly given out just for sympathy.
Chris Colfer in Glee - Colfer took us on a very emotion ride this year through the life of an out gay teenager as he is bullied, picked on and tested to his limits but still manages to get through it all, even with a new partner in the end. While I think Colfer has been the clear highlight of Glee this past season, it does bother me for reasons you've already heard me state in previous categories: it's not funny. His performance is brilliant and emotional and even heartbreaking at times but it doesn't make me laugh (and if it did I should probably see a psychiatrist). While Colfer has shown us this year what a brilliant actor he is, he is dramatic, not comedic, but very good at it.
Who was Left Out
Neil Patrick Harris in How I Met Your Mother - After four straight nominations Harris finds himself bumped by the Modern Family Boys, John Cryer and a boy portraying what Harris really was about 10 years ago. Now that Harris has been outshone he faces an uphill battle to regain the nomination, sadder yet because he has yet to win in this category, giving him even less of a foothold to pull himself up by.
Rainn Wilson in The Office - While Dwight Schrute can sometimes be a little too over the top and ridiculous to be considered superb acting, Wilson had a shining moment this season that I thought were get him a nomination. Picture this: You're stranded on a starless show, and the man who they brought in to bridge the gap wasn't doing so well, and convincing people that the show might not be able to go on. Then, two weeks after the star leaves, his assistant steps up and gives an amazing performance that is hilarious, heartfelt and restores your faith in the show. Dwight's turn as Regional Manager really did give hope to many people that The Office could continue without Carrell, and I think it's a shame he won't be recognized for it.
What my Heart Says - Jon Cryer, because he's a funny and he's the only one on his show to be nominated. Also, he's not on drugs
What my Brain Says - Clearly another win for one of the Modern Family Boys, likely a repeat for Eric Stonestreet
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series
Less dominated by Modern Family, although they still pull in two of the six nominations. Five of these six are repeat nominees, and one of America's favorite actresses mangages to steal spot #6.
The Nominees
The Modern Family Gals: Julie Bowen and Sofia Vergara in Modern Family - While not as domineering in this category as their male counterparts are, the Modern Family Gals still manage to sweep up a third of the total nominations and this year seemed poised for victory now that the incumbent, Jane Lynch, has less of a foothold.
Jane Lynch in Glee - Last year's winner is currently suffering from the same problems that two of her co-stars had in that she is losing a lot of her screen time as Glee becomes more of an ensemble and less star-driven. Luckily for Lynch, she still managed to grab another nomination while leaving co-stars Matthew Morrison and Lea Michele in the dust. The heavy favorite last year, Lynch seems a lot less poised to win this year since she suffers from shorter screen time, which means less jokes about Will Schuester's hair which might cost her the statue. Expect her to be in the hunt, but I think she's fallen behind most of the pack.
Jane Krakowski in 30 Rock - Krakowski gets her 3rd nomination from 30 Rock, and is still looking for her first win, which is unlikely to happen this year. While Krakowski gives a very funny performance as crazy actress/singer Jenna Maroney, I don't believe her character is grounded enough to attract voters, because the Modern Family Gals and Lynch also give off funny performances with much more believable characters.
Betty White in Hot in Cleveland - One of America's new favorite actresses returns to the Emmys after winning last year for Outstanding Guest Actress for her hosting stint on Saturday Night Live. So now that the stakes are raised from Guest to Supporting, does Betty still have enough love from fans to keep winning. My opinion would be to say no and bet on the more likely candidates Lynch and the Modern Family Gals, but you never can really count out Betty.
Kristen Wiig in Saturday Night Live - Wiig is now on her 3rd nomination from SNL, and she looks about as poised to win as she ever has been. Unfortunately, SNL's erractic sketch line-up often ensures that it is extremely hard for one of its cast members to stand out in a single episode, which is what the Academy uses for judging. In fact, it has even been an off year for Wiig, as she has started to retire many of her older characters like the Target Lady and hasn't come back with too many hilarious new ones. However, her acclaimed movie Bridesmaids certainly made sure she was not forgotten during Emmy season and ensured her the nomination, however she is still my last pick to win.
Who was Left Out
Jenna Fischer in The Office - Some people were wondering if this was going to be the year Fischer returned to the Emmys after having not recieved a nomination since The Office's 3rd season. In season 3 Pam was dealing with her feelings for Jim even though at the time he had moved away and by the time he came back he was already with someone else. In the current season she and Jim are already married and have a baby. Pam did take a more prominent role in the series though when she basically promotes herself to office administrator and thus took a little bit more responsibility. However, this didn't seem to resonate with the Academy as much as season 3's sexual tension, so Fischer gets left out again.
What my Heart Says - Jane Lynch, as much as she got off on the sidelines a little, it just made her screen time more precious
What my Brain Says - Sofia Vergara, Lynch's moments were probably a little too precious for their own good and Modern Family may soon own this category as well
Outstanding Guest Actor in a Comedy Series
An often overlooked category, I actually really enjoy the guest acting awards because the field is always open, even actors who have played this character before in prior seasons need to re-prove their relevancy and add something fresh. Saturday Night Live and 30 Rock are the main contributors for this award this year (as they have been for a while) and it seems likely that one of them will take home the award, but just like getting nominated in this category, you just never know.
Will Arnett in 30 Rock - Arnett's portrayal of Devon Bank's is often one of the highlights of any 30 Rock season, and this is his 3rd nomination for 3 different seasons of this character. However, while last year he got the nomination for his hilarious and witty quick back and forths with Alec Baldwin, this year he added a little depth to his performance and traded laughs for a lesson. It obviously worked and he is back for a well-deserved 3rd nomination.
Matt Damon in 30 Rock - Damon earns a nomination for playing Liz Lemon's boyfriend Carol for a few episodes, until the relationship ends after a tense standoff on a plane. While Damon was funny, I think the depth Arnett put into Devon Banks makes Damon 30 Rock's underdog, just like Zach Galifanakis is SNL's underdog to Justin Timberlake.
Idris Elba in The Big C - Interesting choice that one of the nominations goes to an actor in one of the semi-comedies this year. However seeing as how this category is actually pretty competetive this year comedically and it appears that the Academy is favoring pure comedies this year, Elba seems like a long shot to win.
Zach Galifanakis in Saturday Night Live - I was pleasantly suprised by this nomination. While many people were predicting Jim Carrey would get nominated for his time as host, I am glad that the Academy decided on what might be less popular, but I feel the better performance. Galifanakis is a master of subtlety but also knows when to go over the top to produce big laughs. Carrey, at least on his hosting job, felt like he was almost shouting at the audience telling them to laugh (see his Black Swan skit). I am glad Galifanakis got in with his more layered performance, but he is still definitely the underdog, even in just the SNL nominees, to Just Timberlake.
Nathan Lane in Modern Family - Lane ends his theatrical run in the Broadway production of The Adams Family and instead of a Tony manages to go out and get an Emmy nomination instead. Lane was a great fit for the style of Modern Family (in more than one way, if you know what I mean) and it's nice that Lane is getting acting recognition outside of the theatrical community. However, ironic as it may be, he seems poised to lose to someone doing a live show in front of an audience, exactly what theatre is.
Justin Timberlake in Saturday Night Live - In my opinion, the clear frontrunner. Sang two songs, one for his monologue and one with Andy Samberg. Both are nominated for Emmys. Brought it on down to Liquorville. Spoofed himself and NSYNC in a sketch where he couldn't remember his former bandmate's name. Actually didn't break character on the Barry Gibbs talk show. Gave SNL its highest ratings in over a decade. Yeah, we'll give that a nomination.
Who was Left Out
Darren Criss in Glee - Many expected Criss to get a nomination for potraying Kurt Hummel's gay friend and later his boyfriend. Like I've stated about 10 different actors/actresses by now, Criss did a good job acting, he just wasn't that funny. Also, his role on the show was mainly just emotion support for Kurt, so Chris Colfer often outshined him in his scenes which is why Colfer might be sitting on a nomination right now and Criss is not.
Will Ferrell in The Office - I put this in here not so much because a lot of people felt he deserved to be nominated, I just felt that somebody had to talk about it. To start off, I love Will Ferrell, I really do. I think he's hilarious when he's used right. Will, you were not used right on The Office. Your guest spot was one of the most anticipated events of the season but most people were pretty let down afterwards. I'm sorry, it just didn't work out. Go back and host SNL, that will probably go better for you.
What my Heart Says - Will Arnett or Justin Timberlake, I love you both, Arnett finally deserves an Emmy win, but Timberlake was also the highlight of the SNL season
What my Brain Says - Justin Timberlake, you just can't say no to that face
Outstanding Guest Actress in a Comedy Series
While Darren Criss was shut out over on the boys side, on the ladies side Glee is going strong, taking up half the nominations. SNL and 30 Rock have their people in here too, and the gang is rounded out with a well known actress on a new show.
Elizabeth Banks in 30 Rock - Banks had a strong enough run on 30 Rock to snag herself a nomination, but I don't think it will carry all the way up to the stage. Banks, who played Jack Donaghy's wife Avery, had to match Alec Baldwin note for note to be, in essance, the female him. Banks stepped up to the task admirably and while she got as close as just about anyone has gotten to keeping in stride with Baldwin, he always managed to stay one step ahead of her.
Kristen Chenowith in Glee - Most people weren't sure if Chenowith would return again this year as her character April Rhodes, with most critics saying she was outshined by one of Glee's other guest stars this year, Gwyneth Paltrow. While it looks like Chenowith managed to stave off absolute defeat, I still have to agree that Paltrow's character Holly Holiday had more energy, pizzaz and heart going for her.
Tina Fey in Saturday Night Live - Tina Fey once again gets a nomination for hosting a show she used to be head writer for. The main attractant for Fey's nominations these past couple of years is her portrayal of Sarah Palin, which won her this award back in 2009. However, in this hosting stint Fey's Palin only gets a couple of minutes of screen time, which I don't think will be enough to have her win again.
Dot Jones in Glee - While Paltrow is definitely Glee's top contender, Dot Jones managed to pave her way in as well as the coach of the McKinley High School football team. As a woman in an obviously male dominated profession, Jones's performance has had its moments of hilarity and sadness, often in the same episode. I'm glad she's being recognized, but I don't think she'll be able to step out of Paltrow's shadow.
Cloris Leachman in Raising Hope - Leachman was hilarious as Maw Maw in Raising Hope, and her nomination is helping put the sitcom on the map, and establish her as a regular in this category if the show continues, like Will Arnett and Elain Stritch have been on 30 Rock (Up until now for Stritch). I'm not exactly sure how big of a contender Leachman will be for the big prize, but I wish her the best of luck. What's the hurt in trying?
Gwyneth Paltrow in Glee - Paltrow's managed to kick Matthew Morisson out of Glee for most of an episode, and we actually didn't mind that much. Paltrow was good in giving us a break from the normal routine of a Glee episode and mixing things up a little bit. Not to mention, she was funny, and her musical performances were not bad at all, in my opinion. Now that Glee doesn't have to worry about campaigning for Best Actor or Actress anymore, I'm sure a lot of their attention will be focused on getting Paltrow the award, and they'll probably succeed.
Who was Left Out
Elaine Stritch in 30 Rock - Stritch had been nominated four years in a row with one win for playing the mother of Jack Donaghy up until this year, when she was left off the ballot. Rather suprising, as I feel that Stritch was able to keep in stride with Alec Baldwin and even overpower him when needed better than Elizabeth Banks has this year. However, her guest appearance this year wasn't her best as she wasn't given as meaty of a storyline, so it makes sense for Banks to have been given the nod. Besides, there's always next year.
What my Heart Says - Dot Jones, for a greatly undervalued performance, and also to spite Paltrow
What my Brain Says - Gwyneth Paltrow, the frontrunner who most likely seduce the Emmy votes as well as she seduced Will Shuester
Outstanding Variety Program
As a little extra, I've jotted down my thoughts on the Variety programs that have been nominated this year, as they are almost all at least partly comedic in nature, and hey, I like them.
The Colbert Report - With the Daily Show, forms the Twin Towers of late night comedy, except these will most likely never be taken down until their stars are dead. While Colbert is often considered 2nd banana to Jon Stewart and his gang, Colbert still never disappoints for laughs and always manages to keep viewers tuned in after they've already recieved their fake news of the day from Stewart.
Conan - In another little middle finger to Jay Leno, the Academy is being full front on where they stood during NBC's late night debacle by giving Conan O'Brien another nomination for his show but shutting out Jay Leno. To them and many of us, Conan is still Conan no matter which network he's on, and it's good to see that the NBC incident hasn't affected his ability to keep us entertained.
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart - This award's winner for the last....well who can keep track of how many years it's been. That being said, Stewart and co. are still the number 1 source of political satire and managed to consistently deliver laughs, often while being more factual and using better reporting than most news stations. It's going for win number....whatever, and it's probably going to succeed.
Late Night with Jimmy Fallon - The Academy must really want to stick it to Jay, giving a nod to his late night counterpart but not him. I'm not sure that was exactly the right thing to do, especially considering that not only Leno, but even Letterman was shut out this year. While I think Jimmy has the potential to be a good late night host, I don't think he's quite settled into the fold yet, and I feel this nomination might be a little premature.
Real Time with Bill Maher - A show that's literally just about people talking, and it somehow manages to keep people interested, which is why it definitely deserved another nomination. Maher manages to take guests in from all walks of life and ensure that they still have a coherent discussion, which is a skill I'm sure many Washington lawmakers envy.
Saturday Night Live - While not its best season in recent years, SNL's political relevancy this year made sure it stayed one top. While Stewart and Colbert maybe able to make a few jokes about Bin Laden, only on SNL is someone able to dress up in character and give Bin Laden's point of view. Big stories in national news always ensure that SNL stays relevant and in the minds of its viewers, and if not, Justin Timberlake will make sure then that viewers will just come to watch him.
What my Heart Says - The Colbert Report, just because they finally deserve one of these things
What my Brain Says - The Daily Show, it's still at the top of its game, and Stewart will most likely bring home the gold
Now, for the final Emmy category we're going to look at, here's a category where comedy really took hold this year, not exactly in the place you'd most expect
Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics
All 6 of these songs come from either a comedy show or a comedian, 4 from Saturday Night Live and 3 of those specifically coming from the group in charge of the Digital Shorts, The Lonely Island, who won in 2006 for the song "Dick in a Box" and have earned a couple more nominations in this category as well in past years.
The Nominees
"Christmas Time is Killing Us" - Family Guy
"An American Prayer - Hymn II?" - Robert Klein: Unfair & Unbalanced
"I Just Had Sex" - Saturday Night Live
"Jack Sparrow" - Saturday Night Live
"3-Way (The Golden Rule)" - Saturday Night Live
"Justin Timberlake Monologue" - Saturday Night Live
Those are my thoughts on the 2011 emmy situation. Feel free to respond with any questions/comments/concerns and let's try to get a debate going!
Outstanding Comedy Series
The Big Kahuna. Currently held by ABC's Modern Family, 4 nominees from 2010 return again, as well as two "new" series who are first time nominees even though they are both a few seasons into their run.
The Nominees
30 Rock - Tina Fey's quirky show is back for its 5th nomination in 5 years. While its 5th season is not its best, most comedies would kill for what 30 Rock would consider an average season. It is still one of the most brilliantly written shows on television, and to match that it has wonderful actors, who have garnered 6 acting nominations for the show this year. (Alec Baldwin, Tina Fey for Lead, Jane Krakowski for Supporting and Will Arnett, Matt Damon and Elizabeth Banks for Guest)
The Big Bang Theory - Finally getting its 1st nomination for its 4th season, many diehard nerdy fans are screaming happily because their show is finally getting recognition. As it should, it being one of the highest rated comedies currently on air, as well as getting a little bump when one of its stars, Jim Parsons, recieved the Emmy for Lead Actor in a Comedy Series last year. This year, Parson returns to the lead actor ballot, as well as his co-star Johnny Galecki, showing that this show is starting to resonate a little with the Emmy voters.
Glee - It was no question that this hit show would be back for another nomination in this category. I'm not sure if it's right though. While admittedly I was a hardcore Gleek last year and still watched every episode this year, my affection for this show is starting to fade. It's really not even that funny anymore, it has added many more dramatic elements this year as the teens struggle with real life issues, most notably Kurt Hummel's struggles as an out gay teenager. While it did make for some interesting and moving moments, almost none of them made me laugh. Also, the teen's romances are starting to get hard to keep track of, as well as being portrayed almost ridiculouslly unrealistic, which might be there attempt at humor. While still a fine series, Glee has even less evidence to call itself a comedy than last year.
Modern Family - The returning champs return for their 2nd nomination just as everyone and their newborn child could tell they would. There's not much more to say about it than that.
The Office - While the show has definetly hasn't been at its comedic highpoint for about 3 or 4 years, it was pretty much obvious the show would be nominated again for Steve Carrell's departure, especially since his departure was quite well done. Now, the question remains, will the show be able to get nominated again without Carrell? The show needs to re-invent itself and get back to its great mix of wonderful character moments and suprise laughs that its 2nd and 3rd (and to some extent 4th and 5th, though not nearly as well) season showed us.
Parks and Recreation - Its about time. I'm glad this highly undervalued show is finally getting its full turn in the limelight, after only getting a taste last year with Poehler's Lead Actress nomination (a feat she repeats again this year). It seems that adding Rob Lowe and Adam Scott to the cast has finally put this hilarious satire of small town government over the top, though the standouts still remain Poehler and Nick Offerman whose chemistry and character development have been great and led to some wonderful moments. While not the best show out there, it definitely deserves its spot among the nominees.
Who was Left Out
Nurse Jackie - This show, and by extension, all half comedies (The Big C, Weeds) except for Glee, was left out of the race this year. It seems life the Academy was wondering last year if these shows could stand with the pure comedies and compete head to head by giving Nurse Jackie a nomination for Outstanding Comedy Series. It seems that it ended up not being able to compete, so the Academy is instead honoring the more pure comedy shows (The Big Bang Theory, Parks and Recreation) rather than honoring more shows that give us a mix between the comedic and the dramatic.
Community - I am not going to lie to you, I am a big fan of this show. Along with Parks and Recreation, it is one of the dark-horses of NBC's Thursday night line-up. However, one of the best parts of this show, how its style changes almost every week to satarize the many genres and cliches of pop culture, is probaly not going to win over the Academy as much as a show that can prove it can be consistently funny in a single style. While I am a little sad it wasn't nominated, the fact that Parks and Recreation made the cut means I honestly can't complain, and it gives me hope that one day this great show will have its spot in the limelight too.
What my Heart says - Parks and Recreation, just to mess with every major pundit out there
What my Brain says - Modern Family. With Glee taking a more dramatic turn, this show should be clear for another win.
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series
This category was probably the most open category of the year in 2011. Long time nominees Larry David, Tony Schaloub and Charlie Sheen were all ineligible this year,(for different reasons) leading to 3 new nominees. Next year, as we all know, another spot is going to open up, so the big question is will this finally be the year of Carrell?
The Nominees
Alec Baldwin in 30 Rock - Alec Baldwin bags his 5th nomination for portraying Jack Donaghy on 30 Rock, to no one's suprise. Baldwin represents to me the best in a comedy actor, complete and utter devotion to his character whether he's making a speech about how American needs to innovate...by creating women's porn, or talking to 3 of his alternate reality selves. Baldwin utters every single word with complete determination and never attempts an extra laugh by giving the audience the "nudge-nudge, I just told a joke" approach, which I have always highly admired him for.
Steve Carrell in The Office - Is is finally his year? After being shut out in his first five nominations, will Steve Carrell finally take home the golden statue for Michael Scott's departure? I hope so. In Michael's farewell Carrell gave us a great mix of laughter and tears as he says goodbye in the only way he knows how. While not always inducing attacks on our sides, Carrell is a master at building up huge amounts of awkward tension whenever Michael goes to far, a skill that has been undervalued for 5 years, and I sure hope not for a 6th
Louis C.K. in Louie - A suprise nomination, but certainly a well deserved one, and I'm glad about 1,000,000 television cynics can now shut their traps. Louis C.K. has often been called the hardest working man in television, seeing how he oversees almost every detail that goes into making his FX sitcom, Louie. Cynics have long been predicting this year how C.K. deserved a nomination but "the elite at the Academy likely won't see what a wonderful show and performance C.K. give us, they hate good things" so sit down and shut up, you got what you wanted.
Johnny Galecki in The Big Bang Theory - In reality Parsons's second banana, there's no way that Galecki will ever take home the golden idol unless Parsons character mysteriously dies. However, it is nice that he is being honored for his performance along with his show getting its first ever Outstanding Comedy Series nomination. It's well deserved, and he will finally get his own turn in the spotlight after his co-star turned a lot of heads last year with his Emmy win.
Matt LeBlanc in Episodes - Welcome back Joey. Matt LeBlanc is now a member of an exclusive group of people who have been honored with accolades to portray...themselves. LeBlanc now joins the ranks of Bill Cosby and Jerry Seinfeld in actors who have been able to garner acclaim by portraying a fictional version of themselves of television. However, playing yourself isn't always as easy as it seems, and it's good that LeBlanc bounced back to something after the failure of his Friends spin-off.
Jim Parsons in The Big Bang Theory - The returning champ is back, but this time he brought his series with him into a nomination. While another win doesn't seem extremely likely for Parsons, especially due to Carrell's departure, he still continuously puts forth a fine performance and is very worthy of another nomination.
Who was Left Out
Matthew Morrison in Glee - Morrison does not recieve his 2nd nomination for Glee. This year, the spotlight has shown more on the students than the teacher, and it looks like the Academy figured that out.
Joel McHale in Community - Many people thought McHale would finally get Community some Emmy recognition, but it seems that he lost out to C.K. and Galecki. At least he left some people something to complain about.
What my Heart Says - Louis C.K., just because blogs and reporters everywhere will need to find something new to complain about
What my Brain Says - Steve Carrell, I think finally it's his year. and now he won't have to steal Ricky Gervais's Emmy any more
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series
3 new actresses compete for TV's top award, in the category with a few suprise upsets. 1 spot was left open by Julia Louis-Dreyfus but two nominees from 2010 were overturned.
Edie Falco in Nurse Jackie - Last year, Falco got the golden statue for Lead Actress in a Comedy Series, even though, and she said it herself, she's "not funny." While Falco is a great actress I wish they would give this award to someone who is actually comedic. However, since her show is now out of the Outstanding Comedy Series line-up it isn't likely Falco will get repeat statues.
Tina Fey in 30 Rock - Fey earns her 5th nomination, despite her own insistance that she "can't act." While I do think Fey is hilarious and does have acting skill, is she the best? I really don't think so. Most of Fey's reactions on the show involved her being frustrated with something, her co-workers, her actors, her boyfriend, her ex-lovers or her mentor Jack. While Fey still manages to make her frustration funny 5 seasons in, I don't think it should be enough to win.
Laura Linney in The Big C - Linney joins Falco as the two actresses who managed to get a nomination without exactly being "funny." As much as it pains me unfortunately there's not really enough lead female vehicles viable for the top award to take away Linney's spot. While she's a good actress, she's not extremely funny and that's what I believe this category should be about, but her performance still deserves credit.
Melissa McCarthy in Mike & Molly - This morning Melissa McCarthy announced the 2011 Emmy nominations, only to discover that she would be among the nominees. What followed was cool to watch, seeing a nominee react on camera to their nomination. While this is suprising, it would be far more suprising in McCarthy did not have a hilarious supporting role in Kristen Wiig's movie Bridesmaids, which I'm sure some of the Emmy voters saw which was able to put McCarthy into the minds of the voters.
Martha Plimpton in Raising Hope - Another suprise nominee, once again giving the cynics less to complain about. Plimpton now is the face of the Fox network in this category, because the actress that was Fox's only nominee last year, Lea Michele, has been dropped this year. Plimpton is getting her show some much needed attention, sneaking Raising Hope into the minds of the Emmy voters, something that many shows have yet to do (Community).
Amy Poehler in Parks and Recreation - Poehler has achieved her 2nd nomination for Parks and now she dragged her show up with her, and she doesn't seem to be stopping. Poehler was the 1st one to get her show recognition from critics with her quirky, brilliant and optimistic portrayal of a woman who LIKES to work in government. I can only hope she rides it straight to the top, because she doesn't seem to be slowing down anytime soon.
Who was Left Out
Lea Michele in Glee - Michele suffered the same fate of her on screen teacher Morrison this year, albeit to a lesser extent. Glee is very much becoming an ensemble show, which unfortunately for Michele makes each individual performance less notable unless you're the only one on the show able to carry certain storylines (Chris Colfer).
Toni Collette in United States of Tara - Collette won the award in 2009 and was renominated in 2010 but it seems this year that she's fallen off the map. Collette's performance I believe also belongs in the comedy nether-world with Falco and Linney, so it's quite possible it was decided that three semi-comedic performances was too much on the ballot and Linney eclipsed Collette.
What my Heart Says - Amy Poehler, because she's a funny person in a comedic category, shocking
What my Brain Says - Edie Falco or Laura Linney, in a category with not too many standouts one of the semi-comics is likely to take home the prize
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series
Sadly, though supporting comedic performances are often the funniest because they don't require the depth that leads do, this is the category I'll probably be paying the least attention to, due to reasons you'll see.
The Nominees
The Modern Family Boys: Ty Burrell, Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Ed O'Neill, and Eric Stonestreet in Modern Family - This year, instead of half the supporting actor nods the Modern Family Boys take up two-thirds in what I think is a cowardly attempt to get awards while shutting out other great performances. Modern Family nominates none of its actors in the Lead categories, only in supporting, which is why they take up so many of the nominations. This way, they don't have to deal with the higher level competition in the Lead categories. I'm not saying the performances are bad. They're obviously good enough to continue sweeping the supporting categories for years to come. I just wish the show would've had the guts to risk something on a Lead Actor nomination so it could share the supporting spotlight, not hog it.
Jon Cryer in Two and a Half Men - A suprising nomination in that everyone had just about counted him out due to his co-stars blow-up. But this former winner is back for what could be his last nomination, if Ashton Kutcher can't save the show next year. I think this was more of a sympathy pick for the Academy, showing that they still respect Cryer even as everyone lost respect for Charlie Sheen and his show in the process. As much as I would like to show Cryer sympathy, it makes me sad that one of only two spots not given to Modern Family was possibly given out just for sympathy.
Chris Colfer in Glee - Colfer took us on a very emotion ride this year through the life of an out gay teenager as he is bullied, picked on and tested to his limits but still manages to get through it all, even with a new partner in the end. While I think Colfer has been the clear highlight of Glee this past season, it does bother me for reasons you've already heard me state in previous categories: it's not funny. His performance is brilliant and emotional and even heartbreaking at times but it doesn't make me laugh (and if it did I should probably see a psychiatrist). While Colfer has shown us this year what a brilliant actor he is, he is dramatic, not comedic, but very good at it.
Who was Left Out
Neil Patrick Harris in How I Met Your Mother - After four straight nominations Harris finds himself bumped by the Modern Family Boys, John Cryer and a boy portraying what Harris really was about 10 years ago. Now that Harris has been outshone he faces an uphill battle to regain the nomination, sadder yet because he has yet to win in this category, giving him even less of a foothold to pull himself up by.
Rainn Wilson in The Office - While Dwight Schrute can sometimes be a little too over the top and ridiculous to be considered superb acting, Wilson had a shining moment this season that I thought were get him a nomination. Picture this: You're stranded on a starless show, and the man who they brought in to bridge the gap wasn't doing so well, and convincing people that the show might not be able to go on. Then, two weeks after the star leaves, his assistant steps up and gives an amazing performance that is hilarious, heartfelt and restores your faith in the show. Dwight's turn as Regional Manager really did give hope to many people that The Office could continue without Carrell, and I think it's a shame he won't be recognized for it.
What my Heart Says - Jon Cryer, because he's a funny and he's the only one on his show to be nominated. Also, he's not on drugs
What my Brain Says - Clearly another win for one of the Modern Family Boys, likely a repeat for Eric Stonestreet
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series
Less dominated by Modern Family, although they still pull in two of the six nominations. Five of these six are repeat nominees, and one of America's favorite actresses mangages to steal spot #6.
The Nominees
The Modern Family Gals: Julie Bowen and Sofia Vergara in Modern Family - While not as domineering in this category as their male counterparts are, the Modern Family Gals still manage to sweep up a third of the total nominations and this year seemed poised for victory now that the incumbent, Jane Lynch, has less of a foothold.
Jane Lynch in Glee - Last year's winner is currently suffering from the same problems that two of her co-stars had in that she is losing a lot of her screen time as Glee becomes more of an ensemble and less star-driven. Luckily for Lynch, she still managed to grab another nomination while leaving co-stars Matthew Morrison and Lea Michele in the dust. The heavy favorite last year, Lynch seems a lot less poised to win this year since she suffers from shorter screen time, which means less jokes about Will Schuester's hair which might cost her the statue. Expect her to be in the hunt, but I think she's fallen behind most of the pack.
Jane Krakowski in 30 Rock - Krakowski gets her 3rd nomination from 30 Rock, and is still looking for her first win, which is unlikely to happen this year. While Krakowski gives a very funny performance as crazy actress/singer Jenna Maroney, I don't believe her character is grounded enough to attract voters, because the Modern Family Gals and Lynch also give off funny performances with much more believable characters.
Betty White in Hot in Cleveland - One of America's new favorite actresses returns to the Emmys after winning last year for Outstanding Guest Actress for her hosting stint on Saturday Night Live. So now that the stakes are raised from Guest to Supporting, does Betty still have enough love from fans to keep winning. My opinion would be to say no and bet on the more likely candidates Lynch and the Modern Family Gals, but you never can really count out Betty.
Kristen Wiig in Saturday Night Live - Wiig is now on her 3rd nomination from SNL, and she looks about as poised to win as she ever has been. Unfortunately, SNL's erractic sketch line-up often ensures that it is extremely hard for one of its cast members to stand out in a single episode, which is what the Academy uses for judging. In fact, it has even been an off year for Wiig, as she has started to retire many of her older characters like the Target Lady and hasn't come back with too many hilarious new ones. However, her acclaimed movie Bridesmaids certainly made sure she was not forgotten during Emmy season and ensured her the nomination, however she is still my last pick to win.
Who was Left Out
Jenna Fischer in The Office - Some people were wondering if this was going to be the year Fischer returned to the Emmys after having not recieved a nomination since The Office's 3rd season. In season 3 Pam was dealing with her feelings for Jim even though at the time he had moved away and by the time he came back he was already with someone else. In the current season she and Jim are already married and have a baby. Pam did take a more prominent role in the series though when she basically promotes herself to office administrator and thus took a little bit more responsibility. However, this didn't seem to resonate with the Academy as much as season 3's sexual tension, so Fischer gets left out again.
What my Heart Says - Jane Lynch, as much as she got off on the sidelines a little, it just made her screen time more precious
What my Brain Says - Sofia Vergara, Lynch's moments were probably a little too precious for their own good and Modern Family may soon own this category as well
Outstanding Guest Actor in a Comedy Series
An often overlooked category, I actually really enjoy the guest acting awards because the field is always open, even actors who have played this character before in prior seasons need to re-prove their relevancy and add something fresh. Saturday Night Live and 30 Rock are the main contributors for this award this year (as they have been for a while) and it seems likely that one of them will take home the award, but just like getting nominated in this category, you just never know.
Will Arnett in 30 Rock - Arnett's portrayal of Devon Bank's is often one of the highlights of any 30 Rock season, and this is his 3rd nomination for 3 different seasons of this character. However, while last year he got the nomination for his hilarious and witty quick back and forths with Alec Baldwin, this year he added a little depth to his performance and traded laughs for a lesson. It obviously worked and he is back for a well-deserved 3rd nomination.
Matt Damon in 30 Rock - Damon earns a nomination for playing Liz Lemon's boyfriend Carol for a few episodes, until the relationship ends after a tense standoff on a plane. While Damon was funny, I think the depth Arnett put into Devon Banks makes Damon 30 Rock's underdog, just like Zach Galifanakis is SNL's underdog to Justin Timberlake.
Idris Elba in The Big C - Interesting choice that one of the nominations goes to an actor in one of the semi-comedies this year. However seeing as how this category is actually pretty competetive this year comedically and it appears that the Academy is favoring pure comedies this year, Elba seems like a long shot to win.
Zach Galifanakis in Saturday Night Live - I was pleasantly suprised by this nomination. While many people were predicting Jim Carrey would get nominated for his time as host, I am glad that the Academy decided on what might be less popular, but I feel the better performance. Galifanakis is a master of subtlety but also knows when to go over the top to produce big laughs. Carrey, at least on his hosting job, felt like he was almost shouting at the audience telling them to laugh (see his Black Swan skit). I am glad Galifanakis got in with his more layered performance, but he is still definitely the underdog, even in just the SNL nominees, to Just Timberlake.
Nathan Lane in Modern Family - Lane ends his theatrical run in the Broadway production of The Adams Family and instead of a Tony manages to go out and get an Emmy nomination instead. Lane was a great fit for the style of Modern Family (in more than one way, if you know what I mean) and it's nice that Lane is getting acting recognition outside of the theatrical community. However, ironic as it may be, he seems poised to lose to someone doing a live show in front of an audience, exactly what theatre is.
Justin Timberlake in Saturday Night Live - In my opinion, the clear frontrunner. Sang two songs, one for his monologue and one with Andy Samberg. Both are nominated for Emmys. Brought it on down to Liquorville. Spoofed himself and NSYNC in a sketch where he couldn't remember his former bandmate's name. Actually didn't break character on the Barry Gibbs talk show. Gave SNL its highest ratings in over a decade. Yeah, we'll give that a nomination.
Who was Left Out
Darren Criss in Glee - Many expected Criss to get a nomination for potraying Kurt Hummel's gay friend and later his boyfriend. Like I've stated about 10 different actors/actresses by now, Criss did a good job acting, he just wasn't that funny. Also, his role on the show was mainly just emotion support for Kurt, so Chris Colfer often outshined him in his scenes which is why Colfer might be sitting on a nomination right now and Criss is not.
Will Ferrell in The Office - I put this in here not so much because a lot of people felt he deserved to be nominated, I just felt that somebody had to talk about it. To start off, I love Will Ferrell, I really do. I think he's hilarious when he's used right. Will, you were not used right on The Office. Your guest spot was one of the most anticipated events of the season but most people were pretty let down afterwards. I'm sorry, it just didn't work out. Go back and host SNL, that will probably go better for you.
What my Heart Says - Will Arnett or Justin Timberlake, I love you both, Arnett finally deserves an Emmy win, but Timberlake was also the highlight of the SNL season
What my Brain Says - Justin Timberlake, you just can't say no to that face
Outstanding Guest Actress in a Comedy Series
While Darren Criss was shut out over on the boys side, on the ladies side Glee is going strong, taking up half the nominations. SNL and 30 Rock have their people in here too, and the gang is rounded out with a well known actress on a new show.
Elizabeth Banks in 30 Rock - Banks had a strong enough run on 30 Rock to snag herself a nomination, but I don't think it will carry all the way up to the stage. Banks, who played Jack Donaghy's wife Avery, had to match Alec Baldwin note for note to be, in essance, the female him. Banks stepped up to the task admirably and while she got as close as just about anyone has gotten to keeping in stride with Baldwin, he always managed to stay one step ahead of her.
Kristen Chenowith in Glee - Most people weren't sure if Chenowith would return again this year as her character April Rhodes, with most critics saying she was outshined by one of Glee's other guest stars this year, Gwyneth Paltrow. While it looks like Chenowith managed to stave off absolute defeat, I still have to agree that Paltrow's character Holly Holiday had more energy, pizzaz and heart going for her.
Tina Fey in Saturday Night Live - Tina Fey once again gets a nomination for hosting a show she used to be head writer for. The main attractant for Fey's nominations these past couple of years is her portrayal of Sarah Palin, which won her this award back in 2009. However, in this hosting stint Fey's Palin only gets a couple of minutes of screen time, which I don't think will be enough to have her win again.
Dot Jones in Glee - While Paltrow is definitely Glee's top contender, Dot Jones managed to pave her way in as well as the coach of the McKinley High School football team. As a woman in an obviously male dominated profession, Jones's performance has had its moments of hilarity and sadness, often in the same episode. I'm glad she's being recognized, but I don't think she'll be able to step out of Paltrow's shadow.
Cloris Leachman in Raising Hope - Leachman was hilarious as Maw Maw in Raising Hope, and her nomination is helping put the sitcom on the map, and establish her as a regular in this category if the show continues, like Will Arnett and Elain Stritch have been on 30 Rock (Up until now for Stritch). I'm not exactly sure how big of a contender Leachman will be for the big prize, but I wish her the best of luck. What's the hurt in trying?
Gwyneth Paltrow in Glee - Paltrow's managed to kick Matthew Morisson out of Glee for most of an episode, and we actually didn't mind that much. Paltrow was good in giving us a break from the normal routine of a Glee episode and mixing things up a little bit. Not to mention, she was funny, and her musical performances were not bad at all, in my opinion. Now that Glee doesn't have to worry about campaigning for Best Actor or Actress anymore, I'm sure a lot of their attention will be focused on getting Paltrow the award, and they'll probably succeed.
Who was Left Out
Elaine Stritch in 30 Rock - Stritch had been nominated four years in a row with one win for playing the mother of Jack Donaghy up until this year, when she was left off the ballot. Rather suprising, as I feel that Stritch was able to keep in stride with Alec Baldwin and even overpower him when needed better than Elizabeth Banks has this year. However, her guest appearance this year wasn't her best as she wasn't given as meaty of a storyline, so it makes sense for Banks to have been given the nod. Besides, there's always next year.
What my Heart Says - Dot Jones, for a greatly undervalued performance, and also to spite Paltrow
What my Brain Says - Gwyneth Paltrow, the frontrunner who most likely seduce the Emmy votes as well as she seduced Will Shuester
Outstanding Variety Program
As a little extra, I've jotted down my thoughts on the Variety programs that have been nominated this year, as they are almost all at least partly comedic in nature, and hey, I like them.
The Colbert Report - With the Daily Show, forms the Twin Towers of late night comedy, except these will most likely never be taken down until their stars are dead. While Colbert is often considered 2nd banana to Jon Stewart and his gang, Colbert still never disappoints for laughs and always manages to keep viewers tuned in after they've already recieved their fake news of the day from Stewart.
Conan - In another little middle finger to Jay Leno, the Academy is being full front on where they stood during NBC's late night debacle by giving Conan O'Brien another nomination for his show but shutting out Jay Leno. To them and many of us, Conan is still Conan no matter which network he's on, and it's good to see that the NBC incident hasn't affected his ability to keep us entertained.
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart - This award's winner for the last....well who can keep track of how many years it's been. That being said, Stewart and co. are still the number 1 source of political satire and managed to consistently deliver laughs, often while being more factual and using better reporting than most news stations. It's going for win number....whatever, and it's probably going to succeed.
Late Night with Jimmy Fallon - The Academy must really want to stick it to Jay, giving a nod to his late night counterpart but not him. I'm not sure that was exactly the right thing to do, especially considering that not only Leno, but even Letterman was shut out this year. While I think Jimmy has the potential to be a good late night host, I don't think he's quite settled into the fold yet, and I feel this nomination might be a little premature.
Real Time with Bill Maher - A show that's literally just about people talking, and it somehow manages to keep people interested, which is why it definitely deserved another nomination. Maher manages to take guests in from all walks of life and ensure that they still have a coherent discussion, which is a skill I'm sure many Washington lawmakers envy.
Saturday Night Live - While not its best season in recent years, SNL's political relevancy this year made sure it stayed one top. While Stewart and Colbert maybe able to make a few jokes about Bin Laden, only on SNL is someone able to dress up in character and give Bin Laden's point of view. Big stories in national news always ensure that SNL stays relevant and in the minds of its viewers, and if not, Justin Timberlake will make sure then that viewers will just come to watch him.
What my Heart Says - The Colbert Report, just because they finally deserve one of these things
What my Brain Says - The Daily Show, it's still at the top of its game, and Stewart will most likely bring home the gold
Now, for the final Emmy category we're going to look at, here's a category where comedy really took hold this year, not exactly in the place you'd most expect
Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics
All 6 of these songs come from either a comedy show or a comedian, 4 from Saturday Night Live and 3 of those specifically coming from the group in charge of the Digital Shorts, The Lonely Island, who won in 2006 for the song "Dick in a Box" and have earned a couple more nominations in this category as well in past years.
The Nominees
"Christmas Time is Killing Us" - Family Guy
"An American Prayer - Hymn II?" - Robert Klein: Unfair & Unbalanced
"I Just Had Sex" - Saturday Night Live
"Jack Sparrow" - Saturday Night Live
"3-Way (The Golden Rule)" - Saturday Night Live
"Justin Timberlake Monologue" - Saturday Night Live
Those are my thoughts on the 2011 emmy situation. Feel free to respond with any questions/comments/concerns and let's try to get a debate going!
Comedy Thoughts Intro
Hello, and welcome to Comedy Thoughts, the blog that talks all comedy all the time. I hope to provide on this blog thoughts for discussion on comedies new and old, branching all across different mediums: television, film, music, theatre, stand-up, etc. By the end of the day I hope to have a post giving my outlook on these different mediums, then in the future I hope to keep the blog updated with what has been going on comedy-wise in our culture. Please feel free at any times to post your thoughts on my blog as my thoughts are completely subjective and my opinions are seriously no better than yours (Trust me, I have literally no qualifications). That being said, sit back and enjoy the blog!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)